Your Right to Withdraw Your Guilty Plea After the Court Accepts it

It can be harder to take back a guilty plea after the judge accepts it. Here is what you need to show if you change your mind before or after sentencing.

Pre-Sentencing

In many cases, there will be another hearing to sentence you after you plead guilty. You may be able to withdraw your plea before you are sentenced if you can show a fair and just reason for your decision. The judge would consider many factors in deciding whether to grant your request, such as your reasons, the length of time between your plea and your request to withdraw it, and whether you had an attorney at the time of your guilty plea.

Post-Sentencing

It is much harder to withdraw a guilty plea after sentencing. You would need to show that it would be manifestly unjust to enter a guilty plea given the circumstances of your case. This is a much harder standard of proof than showing a fair and just reason to withdraw your plea.

Common Reasons the Judge Could Agree to Withdraw Your Plea

There are many reasons why a judge may agree to allow you to withdraw your guilty plea. Some of the most common reasons are:

  • You had the ineffective assistance of a lawyer. This is probably the most common reason a judge would grant your request to withdraw your plea.
  • You were not represented by an attorney when you pled guilty.
  • You were not mentally competent to enter your plea.
  • Your plea was entered without your consent.
  • The strength of your defenses to the charges you face has risen.
  • You were manipulated or threatened in order to get you to plead guilty.
  • Your constitutional rights were violated, such as the police continued to question you after you exercised your right to remain silent or you were deprived of your right to an attorney.
Howard W. Long, II
Connect with me
Charlotte Criminal Defense and DWI Lawyer